I've spent real time in both cities. And every time someone says "I want a Caribbean city trip with colonial architecture and great nightlife," the same two names come up. Havana and Cartagena look similar in photos — colorful buildings, cobblestone streets, salsa music — but they're radically different experiences.
Let me break down exactly where each city wins, loses, and who should go where.
On paper, they're twins. Both are 500-year-old Spanish colonial port cities on the Caribbean. Both have UNESCO-listed old towns with pastel buildings. Both have rum, salsa, and warm water. Both show up on every "best Caribbean cities" list.
But Havana is in Cuba. And that changes everything.
Cartagena wins.
Cartagena (CTG airport) has direct flights from Miami, Fort Lauderdale, New York, and several European cities. No special paperwork. Colombia gives you 90 days visa-free if you hold a US, UK, or EU passport.
Havana (HAV airport) requires US travelers to have a reason under one of 12 authorized categories, buy a pink tourist card ($50-100 at the airline), and deal with regulations that shift unpredictably. Non-US travelers have it easier, but it's still more bureaucratic.
If you want the path of least resistance, Cartagena is simpler.
Cartagena wins by a landslide.
Cartagena: ATMs everywhere. Credit cards accepted at most restaurants and hotels. Apple Pay works at modern establishments. Colombian pesos from any ATM.
Havana: US-issued cards don't work. Period. European cards work sporadically. You need to bring enough cash in EUR or USD for your entire trip and exchange at official CADECA offices. This is not an exaggeration — it's the reality of traveling in Cuba.
I've met tourists in Havana who ran out of cash on Day 3 of a 7-day trip. It's genuinely stressful.
| Type | Havana | Cartagena |
|---|---|---|
| Budget | Casa particular: $25-50/night | Hostel: $12-25/night, guesthouse: $30-60 |
| Mid-range | Boutique casa: $50-100 | Boutique hotel: $80-200 |
| Luxury | Hotel Nacional: $150-300 | Sofitel Santa Clara: $250-500 |
Verdict: Tie. Havana's casas particulares are uniquely charming and the breakfast-included model is unbeatable. Cartagena has more range and polish.
Havana's casas give you something no hotel can: a Cuban family. Marta at my casa on Calle Obispo cooked me a $10 lobster dinner and shared stories about growing up during the Special Period. You don't get that at a Sofitel.
But if you want reliable hot water, fast Wi-Fi, and a swimming pool, Cartagena has you covered.
Cartagena wins on diversity. Havana wins on price.
Cartagena's food scene has exploded. Ceviche, arepas de huevo, seafood rice, and a fine-dining scene in the walled city that rivals any Latin American capital. Dinner at a top restaurant: $25-50 per person.
Havana's food has improved dramatically with the paladar revolution, but options are more limited. A great paladar dinner: $8-15 per person. Ropa vieja, lobster, tostones — the hits are genuine. But after a week, you start to feel the limited variety.
Honestly, the $10 lobster dinner at a Havana casa is one of the best value meals in the Caribbean. But Cartagena's La Cevicheria (the one Bourdain visited) serves a passion-fruit ceviche that makes me emotional just remembering it.
Havana wins — and it's not close.
Cartagena's walled city is gorgeous and well-maintained. Flower-draped balconies, colorful facades, immaculate plazas.
Havana's Old Town is rawer, larger, and more dramatic. The crumbling facades haven't been polished for tourists. Some buildings are falling down while the one next door has been beautifully restored. The scale is also different — Havana's colonial core is much bigger than Cartagena's walled city.
Plus, Havana has the Malecon. That 8-km seawall is unlike anything Cartagena offers. At sunset, with half the city gathered to socialize, fish, and play music, it's one of those travel moments that rewires your brain.
Tie — but completely different.
Cartagena: polished nightlife in Getsemani, rooftop bars in the walled city, organized salsa nights at Cafe Havana (the irony). It's fun, accessible, and runs late.
Havana: rougher edges but more character. Fabrica de Arte Cubano ($2 entry) is the best cultural venue I've been to in the Americas. Callejon de Hamel's Sunday rumba is raw and unforgettable. The honky-tonk style bars on Obispo have live music until late.
If you want a polished night out, Cartagena. If you want something you'll remember for twenty years, Havana.
Both require awareness.
Cartagena has more petty crime — phone snatching on the street, drink spiking in bars (don't leave drinks unattended), and scam taxis. But serious violence against tourists is rare.
Havana has almost no violent crime against tourists. But scams are relentless: fake cigar sellers, restaurant touts, inflated taxi prices. The "the cigar factory is closed" routine happens every ten minutes on Obispo.
I felt safer walking alone in Havana at 1AM than in Cartagena. But my wallet was more at risk from scams in Havana.
Cartagena wins decisively.
Cartagena: Wi-Fi at most hotels and restaurants. 4G/5G data works. You can work remotely here.
Havana: Wi-Fi at ETECSA hotspots in parks and hotel lobbies. Buy scratch cards for $1-2/hour. It's slow. It's frustrating. And it's actually kind of wonderful — you're forced to be present.
| You are... | Go to... | Because... |
|---|---|---|
| First-time Latin America traveler | Cartagena | Easier logistics, more tourist infrastructure |
| Experienced traveler wanting something different | Havana | Nothing else like it on Earth |
| Couple on a romantic trip | Cartagena | More reliable dining, luxury options |
| Solo traveler on a budget | Havana | Casas are social, everything is cheap |
| History buff | Havana | Deeper, more complex, more layers |
| Foodie | Cartagena | More variety and higher ceiling |
| Digital nomad | Cartagena | Internet actually works |
| Someone who wants to unplug | Havana | No choice — embrace it |
Cartagena is the easier, more comfortable trip. It's beautiful, the food is great, and the logistics are straightforward. For more insights, check out our complete guide to Havana. For more insights, check out our Havana travel journal.
Havana is harder. It requires more planning, more cash, more patience. But it gives you something Cartagena can't: the feeling that you're somewhere truly unlike anywhere else. The isolation, the vintage cars, the creative energy in places like FAC, the rhythm of life along the Malecon — it stays with you.
If you can only pick one, ask yourself this: do you want to be comfortable, or do you want to be changed?
Cartagena is the comfortable choice. And there's nothing wrong with that.
But Havana? Havana changes you.
Travel Guides
Travel Guides
Travel Guides
